Voter Number # 1 in Montclair and Bloomfield!
Voter Number # 2 in Essex County!
Voter Number # 3 in North Jersey!
Welcome To Amore Pizza
by jack calandra
Since 1989
Pizza Nutley NJ – The pursuit for the very best Pizza Restaurant is finally over…
Salads
Pizza
Chicken Wings
For 35 years Amore Pizza by jack calandra has kept our customers coming back for our Delicious Pizza here in Nutley NJ. Starting in two locations in Newark, then opening in Bloomfield and Montclair our mom and pop shop, adjacent to Nutley, is home to the most desirable Pizza in Essex county and beyond. Now exclusively in Nutley NJ.
One Bite – Amore Pizza By jack calandra
Amore Pizza By jack calandra is one of Nutley’s finest pizzerias!
Hours
Mon to Fri: 10:00 am – 9:00 pm
Sat: 10:00 am – 9:00 pm
Sun: CLOSED
Pick-Up, Delivery, Indoor and Outdoor dinning!
James Weidenbacher
18:07 01 Jun 24
Robert John Fallon
14:55 01 Jun 24
Great variety of Pizza
The chicken parmigiana is incredible.
And the service was outstanding.
I highly recommend 👌.
The chicken parmigiana is incredible.
And the service was outstanding.
I highly recommend 👌.
Anthony Sgotto
14:51 01 Jun 24
Jack is a true pizza artist. His pies are truly unique and delicious! Minchia!!
Cayla Lombardi
02:40 31 May 24
Best pizza around. Couldn’t recommend this place more!
Steven LoPorto
17:28 30 May 24
Just went to Amore Pizza for the first time and it’s my new go to place for a slice. The food is great and the staff couldn’t be more friendly.
Gianna C
16:05 30 May 24
The best pizza. From the outdoor seating to the friendly staff that makes you feel like you’re family, this place is stellar.
Jake Meola
15:48 30 May 24
Pizza was amazing, this is what quality pizza from Italians should be like. Possibly one of my new favorite places. This is a small family that owns and runs this place. Had a wonderful conversation with an older gentleman and an older woman. They were so nice and welcoming, this is what real NJ pizza is about, great pizza and great people.
jack farrell
14:54 30 May 24
I love this place. Great pizza and always have a variety to choose from. The thin crust with the homemade sauce is the perfect combo. If you haven’t been, you should give it a try. The outdoor area they have is also perfect for friends and family get togethers.
Gabriella Cangiamila
23:44 25 May 24
Amore is my go to pizza place they never disappoint! This pizza is unlike any I’ve had before with a tasty, well done crust and delicious homemade sauce. A must try if you’ve never been!
Darius Anderson
19:54 06 Mar 24
Great tasting pizza, rich sauce, great cheese this is like a real quick bite to eat. Two slices and a soda came up to eight dollars again great pizza don’t do what I do and put your head in the window. They serve pizza out of a shake shack like a window , great pizza great service I’ll be back 5 stars
If you enjoyed your Amore Pizza experience and pizza, please give us a review on Google!
” Pizza is amazing!! I ordered a thin crust pie (well done of course) and it was cooked to perfection. The sauce has a sweet taste to it that some might not like but I think it’s awesome! The crust was crispy, a little flop, a little greasy but not over the top. I would definitely be stopping here whenever I’m in the mood for pizza. I’ve tried the other places in town and I think this might be the best one. “
– Prince Nelson
” I have order a regular pie on several occasions, the menu looks great and offers a bunch of different kinds. However, I’ve only got the reg pie…if you were looking for a nice well done pie, this is it. Their sauce is different than any other which makes a statement, it’s slightly sweet like moms Sunday gravy. The cheese is well done not gooey and crust is thin slight crunch to the touch it. Def one of my favs in town at the moment. Also delivery has always been super quick keeping in mind that I usually order weekdays before 5 PM. “
– Melissa Rogerio
” Everything is delicious! Friendly staff and easy to order from. Definitely one of my go to places for yummy pizza and Italian dishes! If you haven’t tried Amore you are MISSING OUT!!!! “
– Tiffany Nejat
” The Giuseppe is phenomenal. The crust is crispy yet airy with a little garlic kick to it. I also loved the grandma slice. Worth the 50 min drive. Can’t wait to go back. “
– Mike S
” Our new pizza spot. Going to pick up another order in about 20 minutes. Margherita is the best I’ve had in a long time if you’re into thin crust and crispy pizza. “
– Steven Price